Showing posts with label education in Pakistan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label education in Pakistan. Show all posts

Monday, 7 July 2014

Teaching: Dearth of subject specialists in schools.

Teaching: Dearth of subject specialists in schools

Published Oct 06, 2013 in Sunday Images
Teaching and learning determine the effectiveness of a teacher. Teaching is generally valued with academic research, behavioural analysis and judgment of students to involve them in authentic learning. The present vision of effective teaching is defined by analysing the behavioural patterns of the class and innovative teaching methodologies, which ensure delivering a vast knowledge of the subjects being taught to young students and is generally reflected by their improved grades.
The student’s learning mainly depends upon a teacher’s education, knowledge about the subject and way of teaching that subject. Over the past few years, it has been observed that the number of teachers with relevant subject qualification has declined in the schools. The shortages of subject specialists in Pakistani schools have led to an incompetent academic performance of the schools and non-professional teaching environment in classrooms.
In most schools, both primary and secondary level teachers are assigned to teach at least two subjects. The combination of subjects varies differently in schools, for instance English and History, Science and Computer, Urdu and Geography, Islamiat and Mathematics may be combined. The school management does not even bother to consider whether the concerned teacher has the knowledge and capability to teach the subject. Therefore it is most probable that the children are not being properly taught by the teacher who is not a subject specialist.
The blame goes to the school management, who at the time of selection, hire under-qualified and incompetent individuals on low salaries. Due to severe unemployment in the country most people opt to enter the profession of teaching. As a result, a majority of teachers in schools lack the teaching skills and motivational techniques to help students learn in a creative way.
According to the principal of a private school, their budget does not permit to have subject specialists at every level in the school.
During my visit to a private school, I was informed by the students of grade seven and eight that the subject of History was being taught to them by an Urdu teacher. They found their History period too boring and unexciting. The teacher came to the class unprepared, without lesson planning, and was unable to deliver the lecture clearly. Therefore, the students instead of attending the class found some other alternative to pass the time and engaged themselves in playing games.
I also observed that during the lecture the teachers do not captivate and stimulate pupils with exciting ideas. They ask them to read the topic while no introduction and discussion of the topic is done. The teacher writes question and answers on the blackboard. Students copy down the work having no understanding of what is been taught. Moreover, students are also assigned homework and written assignments but no teacher’s guidance and assistance is provided which could make their work interesting.
Parents agree that ineffective teaching affects the learning of the children. Students can not enhance their knowledge and learning from incompetent teachers. Thus, there is a risk of losing interest in their studies. Similarly, other parents said, “Someone who is a teacher of Mathematics might not feel comfortable with teaching the rules of grammar and punctuation in English language. This can only be done by an efficient and dedicated English teacher.”
A teacher while sharing her views said that during her 10-year teaching career, she taught different subjects at both primary and secondary levels. She believed that it really does not matter if the teacher is not subject qualified to teach certain topics. What matters is that the teacher can engage, entertain and inspire children to learn more. Only an outstanding teacher can engage children most effectively in any subject.
I believe that students at the primary level are more in need of subject-specialist teachers since early education is a particularly formative time for young children when they get inspired by the positive experiences and behaviour of the teachers, gain knowledge and develop interest in the subject. The basic skill of a child is groomed by someone who by applying innovative teaching methodologies increases a student’s love for the subject which they could take up for higher studies. Children who were taught by under-qualified teachers at the primary level faced great problems when they went on to secondary school. Inadequate conceptual understanding of the subject created more trouble since the teacher never emphasised to study the subject in depth. Due to ineffective teaching their learning remains stagnant.
As we see that education becomes more challenging for students at the secondary level, it is essential that the subject teachers have sound academic backgrounds and vast knowledge of their subjects. The teacher also plays a pivotal role by providing clear guidelines to the students regarding choosing the subject for their future education.
I still remember my English teacher in Grade VIII, the best teacher I have ever seen. Her teaching capabilities revolve around choosing creative techniques, which arouse thinking creatively in students and sorting their opinions. These strategies build up the learning skills of the children. While teaching English novels and plays and English Grammar, she made the environment of the classroom more exciting and interesting, the students filled with curiosity, and enthusiasm enjoyed and enhanced their speaking and writing skills. The boring novels or plays appear to be so attractive as we students began to feel that we had become a part of the dramatic scene.
Our schools desperately need outstanding subject specialists, possessing a sense of motivation and passion and quest of knowledge of not only improving their teaching expertise but also assist the students to explore new ways to enhance their learning process. The school management at the time of selection must conduct a teachers’ certification test. The multiple subject tests are designed to assess teaching capabilities of a teacher .These tests will assist in selecting those individuals who are eligible for the teaching profession and could teach the subject well. I also suggest that after selection of the teachers, teachers’ training courses must be conducted in the schools for assisting the teachers to use modern methodologies and motivational techniques to make their teaching more interactive.
The writer is a teacher.
sadiawali@hotmail.com

Thursday, 3 July 2014

Bring life to learning and learning to life


 written by Sadia Wali

Children are naturally inventive so they do not have to be taught to be creative. Perhaps they need guidance; motivation and inspiration to boost up their creativity .Hence Research, design, and evaluation provide the opportunity to young children to enhance their intellectual learning. The concept of research development as fundamental to educational change is not yet accepted by our educational institutions as many schools still believe in traditional teaching methodologies. Let us first understand what educational research is? Education research is a field of inquiry, the systematic generation of new knowledge, development of new ideas and experiment with new techniques. Clear open-minded questions calls for real research and thinking and gives way of evaluating answers. It aims at advancing knowledge of education and learning processes and development to others.
 Teachers’ learning and professional development is not valued very highly in Pakistan. They are merely trained as classroom teachers. The research- based teacher training culture is hardly seen in Pakistani schools.  Research culture has made its way into higher educational institutes, but not in schools. School heads and Principals just expect teachers to teach their students not to lead them. Teachers are required to teach the syllabus prescribed by school. They are not encouraged to experiment with new innovative approaches of teaching. If anyone who shares a new idea from a book or design creative activities for students he is criticized. In such schools, positive views of professional learning are countercultural. Due to negative and unsupportive attitude of the school management, teachers do not bother to take interest in research and are compelled to use traditional teaching methods.  Thus, negative teaching culture has seriously impaired learning skills of teachers.
To respond to these challenges, many educationists have confusion and constraints in their minds how can they make school research oriented?  What goals and strategies to be adopted to create research learning environment in the schools?

Today, mostly schools are using research culture in their schools however they are not aware that their teaching methodologies are based on research. The teaching strategy used in classrooms is action research strategy. Action research involves three forms of research, Exploratory research, Evaluative and Experimental research. The teacher uses research element in developing the curriculum, content and activities. To make the classroom climate interactive, teacher uses teaching methods include group discussion, individual presentation, searching information from library and internet and creative writing tasks. The research projects introduced in classroom helps to explore student learning strategy and also strengthen student-teacher relationship.
 To promote teacher as a researcher and a proactive learner, work place learning i.e. school is considered as essential element in enhancing the professional development of teachers. The work place must create continuous learning opportunities for teachers and encourage them to reflect and experiment with the new ideas or new skills in classroom practice. Many teachers believe that they learn most effectively from the judgment and perception of their students in the classroom. The important source of learning for teachers is co-operative learning in which teachers collaborate their new ideas and modern teaching methods with their colleagues.
 Some schools are following Observation and assessment approach which is also beneficial for enhancing teacher professional development. This includes peer coaching and teacher evaluation which encourage teachers to improve their professional competencies. The teacher as a person and learner has to develop skills, qualities and attitudes such as commitment, confidence and flexibility, passion for learning, analytic and conceptual thinking to enhance his professional skills.
The unifying purpose of stimulating education research in children is to give them an inspiring vision. The curriculum, modes of instruction, assessments and learning opportunities should be clearly linked with natural environment, and developed to cater the needs and interests of the students. The first hand experience in a child’s education comes from nature. Dienes (1969) suggests that children need to build or construct their own concepts from within rather than having those concepts imposed upon them. This means that children at very young age are inquisitive about their surroundings and have a desire to explore them. It is the responsibility of teachers to let children explore, think and question. The questions formed in mind enhance learning and intellectual capabilities of young children.
 The present scenario implies that change of culture in schools empowers teachers, students and communities to collectively work for a change. Research and development has great significance in shaping learning communities. The first step to raise awareness among teachers and parents regarding bringing a meaningful change in our education system is the collective acceptance of rethinking schooling. Workshops, seminar and other training sessions provide a platform to teachers and educationists to collectively think about redefining their goals and objectives. Having same vision in mind, an educational institution organized   a seminar which focused on enhancing research culture in schools. The guest speakers in the seminar talked about the significance of research in teaching and learning and ponder over various reasons which are causing hindrance in increasing research skills among teachers and students.
 The focal point of the seminar was to emphasize a radical change in education system. The change has been centered on the need for schools to create an environment which is conducive to promoting research skills in teachers and students. We need to provide the learners with a fundamental precept of Islamic education integrated with Islamic tarbiyah. An eminent Muslim political thinker Al-Mauwardi in his book entitled “ The leadership and Politics” writes that the essential characteristic  for a Muslim educator is to have knowledge, Perception, Intellect, Intuition and Revelation which enhances research skills in teachers and students. Ibn Qayyim Al-Jawziyyah  may  Allaah  have  mercy  upon  him said: "To gain knowledge and research in children an educator should encourage children to be creative and inquisitive and ask questions. Children should remain quiet and listen attentively and understand well. And lastly act upon the knowledge being gained.
The seminar outlined the fact there is a general consensus that schools need to adopt research teaching approaches but this process of change is still a big challenge for various schools who still believe in unreflective and conventional teaching methods. Radical change in education is impossible unless education leaders critically analyses and understand the goals and objectives of research in educational development. Research element reveals that transmission-of-knowledge, values and beliefs into classroom practices offers multiple opportunities for students and teachers to improve their effectiveness and efficiency.
The writer is a research fellow at ERDC.



Welcome to learning innovations

I have created this blog to highlight the changes and innovations in the field of education in Pakistan. Our youth has great potential and talent and they are making remarkable services in their field. They need right guidance to enhance their talent and learning.